This month, we were joined by GSF Executive Director Katie Stoll, MS, CGC, and GSF Genetic Counselor Devin Shuman, MS, CGC, to discuss how medical providers can better support patients and families through Electronic Health Record (EHR) documentation. How information is documented and shared through EHRs can have a meaningful impact on patient experiences, particularly when navigating unexpected genetic test results or complex healthcare decisions. We explored strategies for preparing patients to receive results, helping patients advocate for themselves with their other healthcare providers, connecting families with educational and support resources, and documenting sensitive healthcare decisions.


Current Landscape

We are all familiar with examples of patients receiving genetic screening or testing results through their online health portal before they’ve had a chance to talk with their provider. These experiences can be distressing and confusing. 

Why are patients receiving results before speaking with their provider? In 2016, the 21st Century Cures Act was passed, requiring healthcare providers to give patients access to their health information without delay, including genetic test results. There are narrow exceptions that may allow providers to delay releasing information, such as per patient request or when doing so could reasonably endanger the physical health or safety of a patient or another person. 

In this month’s meeting, Devin and Katie shared some of the challenges providers face when navigating these requirements. For example:

  • Delaying results must be considered on a case-by-case basis; providers cannot establish blanket delays for particular types of results, such as genetic test results.
  • Patient anxiety or a provider’s desire to review results before releasing them are not, on their own, considered sufficient reasons to delay a release of results. 
  • Even if a provider requests that results be delayed in the EHR patient portal, patients who have also registered an account with the genetic testing laboratory (for example, to receive billing estimates) may be immediately notified and provided the results within the lab patient portal.
  • Patients must be sent results when requested, even if a patient may not be certain what specific information is within these results (i.e., they may want predicted fetal sex but may also find out health information on their pregnancy).

As a result, patients may receive unexpected results before having an opportunity to discuss them with their healthcare provider. This creates an important opportunity for providers and advocacy organizations to consider how they can better prepare families and ensure supportive resources are readily available.


Recommendations

Katie Stoll and Devin Shuman shared their own strategies for supporting patients through this process.

Setting Expectations

One of the most important strategies discussed was preparing patients in advance for how and when they might receive test results. Providers can explain that results may arrive at any time, including overnight or on weekends, and that patients may not be able to reach someone immediately to answer their questions.

It is also helpful to explain that laboratory reports can be confusing and easy to misinterpret without a provider present. For example, prenatal screening reports may list several conditions being screened for, which can lead patients to mistakenly believe that their baby has all of the listed conditions. Providers can encourage patients to consider ahead of time when and where they open their results, particularly if they would prefer to have a partner or support person present.

Documenting Medical Decisions

Another important discussion centered on how reproductive decisions are documented and communicated across healthcare teams. Patients may find themselves repeatedly asked about decisions they have already made, including whether they want prenatal diagnostic testing or whether they would like to continue a pregnancy. Having to revisit these conversations can leave patients feeling that their decisions are being questioned or that they need to repeatedly justify their choices.

Several strategies can help providers communicate patient preferences across healthcare teams:

  • Document patient preferences explicitly in medical notes and use clear language to indicate when a patient does not wish to revisit a particular discussion (limitation: providers will not always review previous documentation before appointments or may feel obligated to “check in” about the decision).
  • Use internal “sticky notes” in the EHR to communicate decisions with other providers (limitation: these notes are not always noticed or available).
  • Set automatic, pop-up alerts to notify providers of important information (limitation: implementing these features within a healthcare system can be difficult and may not be available).
  • Route notes to a patient’s previously seen primary care provider or OB/GYN (limitation: patients often see different providers throughout their care, and may be purposefully scheduled with every OB/GYN on a team so that they know everyone who may be “on call” at the time of delivery).

The common thread? There is no perfect, easy solution to ensure that all providers are aware of sensitive decisions. The best approach is therefore to help patients understand why providers sometimes revisit previously discussed options and empower them to advocate for themselves.

Providers may feel obligated to offer testing or discuss available options to ensure patients have received appropriate information and an opportunity for further discussion. While these conversations may feel like they are pressuring patients, providers may be trying to ensure that patients have another opportunity to ask questions, access information, or change their minds if their preferences have evolved.

Preparing patients for these interactions can help them communicate their preferences confidently. For example, patients can be encouraged to explain at the beginning of an appointment that they have already made a decision and do not wish to revisit the discussion. They could also share a birth plan based on their preferences, and upload a written birth plan to their chart. This allows patients to establish their boundaries while recognizing that they can always ask more questions and express if their preference changes.


Medical Outreach

Together, we discussed how best practices might be shared with providers through medical outreach.

Provide Template Text

Developing reusable message templates (called “SmartPhrases” in Epic) is a practical way to improve communication. Genetic counselors and advocacy organizations can collaborate to develop supportive, plain-language messages that providers can adapt and save within their own EHR systems.

For example, these templates could include:

  • Explanations of what test results mean for both medical documentation and messages to patients.
  • Guidance on appropriate next steps.
  • Contact information to speak with a healthcare provider.
  • For positive results: Balanced, condition-specific information and links to reputable organizations, educational materials, and family support programs.

Sharing these templates with medical providers and healthcare institutions may make it easier and faster for providers to share thoughtful information following the release of results. It may also give providers the opportunity to see how language preferences have evolved in recent years and easily incorporate these changes into their communications.

Establishing clinic-wide protocols for sharing resources following a diagnosis may also help ensure families receive consistent information, regardless of which provider delivers the news. For example, clinics could routinely direct families to relevant Lettercase educational materials or share Jack’s Basket resources following a Down syndrome diagnosis.

Tell Stories

Sharing stories during medical outreach can be a powerful way to help providers better understand the experiences of patients and families. For example, presenting a written story or video about someone receiving unexpected results without a provider or support person present can help illustrate the emotional impact of these experiences to healthcare providers.

Lunch & Learn presentations and other educational opportunities can give providers the chance to hear directly from individuals and families, consider different perspectives, and better understand how their communication practices affect patients.

Understanding Patient Next Steps

We also discussed the importance of understanding what patients actually do after receiving unexpected results without immediate access to a healthcare provider. Are they searching Google, turning to AI tools, visiting social media, or seeking out advocacy organizations?

Understanding these behaviors could help organizations identify opportunities to make reliable resources easier to find. Strategies might include:

  • Using tools such as Google Analytics
  • Improving search engine optimization (SEO)
  • Exploring targeted Google advertising
  • Boosting organic social media posts
  • Giving feedback to AI tools when answers provided are inaccurate

Organizations should also consider how advertising language and search strategies influence the audiences they reach. For example, emphasizing that resources are free can sometimes attract requests from individuals outside the intended audience.

Written Documentation for Families

Just as written documentation can help providers communicate with one another, putting patient preferences in writing can be particularly effective for families advocating for themselves. Written communication creates a record that can be shared with the healthcare team and helps ensure that patient preferences are clearly communicated.

Examples include submitting a written birth plan, providing a letter outlining healthcare preferences, or formally documenting concerns about a provider’s communication. Starting conversations about accommodations or preferences in writing can help ensure that patients’ decisions are clearly communicated and taken seriously. (Plus, it helps reduce the game of telephone between patients and providers!)

Advocacy organizations can support families by providing practical tools such as birth plan templates and letters that patients can share with their providers. Updating and expanding these resources could help families communicate their preferences while also giving providers opportunities to learn from patient feedback. See our example of a Birth Plan.


Summary

While there are limitations to what providers can control within EHR systems, strategies such as setting expectations, developing reusable message templates, sharing educational resources, and supporting patient self-advocacy can make a meaningful difference. Through continued collaboration between healthcare providers, genetic counselors, and advocacy organizations, we can help ensure families receive not only timely information, but also the context, resources, and support they need to navigate their healthcare decisions.